The S&P 500 is only about 4% off its all-time high and yet bearish sentiment is nearing historic levels. The stock market gains over the last four and a half months have been erased as investors reduce their exposure to many risk assets in the US and take money off the table. The Bull-Bear spread, as it’s called, has only been lower 10 times in the last 30 years. Historically, returns over the ensuing 6-12 months are quite robust, with an average gain of 22% after one year. Only once were they lower, and that was by a miniscule 0.35%. Sentiment readings at this level are what you would expect to see during major market bottoms, not near all-time highs.
It’s hard to pinpoint exactly why investors are so bearish when overall investment performance has been strong, but there are some sensible reasons to point to also. For one, portfolios really haven’t budged much in the last 6 months. Technology companies have been on a historic run over the past few years and now they make up a hefty weighting in the indices and in individual portfolios. So when they stall, the market typically stalls too. Nvidia, for example, shot up 300% from the start of last year into summer, but has since taken a well-deserved breather and is trading at essentially the same price, and it makes up nearly 8% of the Nasdaq 100 index. Their earnings are still growing at a phenomenal rate and even after their meteoric rise NVDA is trading at a cheaper earnings multiple than Apple, so another leg higher (especially after the recent sell-off) could be coming. Another reason for pessimism is all the tariff talks. Whether tariffs are good or bad for an economy is debatable. Regardless of the outcome, big policy changes like these take years to work their way through the system but businesses must adapt quickly. In the short term, major policy changes disrupt business plans and throw chaos into the markets. Imagine being a manufacturer and suddenly a key part doubles in price due to a new tax or is no longer allowed to be imported. Chaos. This could be why we are seeing such strength in markets abroad. Dollars are chasing relative certainty.
Outside of the US, global equities are on a tear. Asia, Europe, and Latin America are all outperforming US markets. This isn’t necessarily a bad thing for US equities. It just shows that breadth is still expanding and now it’s not just new US sectors participating in the bull market but global equities as well. We have discussed sector rotation and breadth expansion in the past here. Rotation is the lifeblood of a bull market and breadth expansion signifies its health. We are seeing more and more stocks participating in the 3yr old bull market. Simply because we are experiencing a bit of a stall and pull-back in US equities does not mean that the bull market is canceled here. We would need to see much more confirming evidence first. An expansion in the list of stocks making new lows versus new highs, for example. The number of stocks that have declined by 20% from their highs is creeping up (to levels not seen since November of 2023), but still nowhere near critical levels. As investors, we might be a little more cautious today than we were a few weeks or months ago, but we are still looking for more things to buy rather than to sell. And with breadth expanding it is presenting us with new opportunities to capture growth. Developed markets have done the best, markets like Germany and Italy. Some of these international indices are bumping up against all-time highs not seen since before the financial crisis of 2008. China and emerging markets have also been on the move, though are much further from their former highs. However, if this trend is going to continue and we are going to see more countries breaking out to new highs, then the dollar will likely have to weaken. Weak dollars make foreign investments more valuable here. A US investor will receive more dollars back if the investment they hold overseas has a strengthening local currency. But a weakening dollar is also a tailwind for US equities since so many of our companies derive much of their business from outside the US. So, if the dollar continues to weaken (as it has done steadily over the last few months) this would bode well for equities in general and might finally be the kicker that boots global stocks back into favor, even if sentiment here in the US remains in the doldrums.